July 23, 2009 2:45 PM BST
heres my 10p worth
...
For me, going stealth would be dishonest and maybe imply I was ashamed of who I was? I believe anyone going stealth, unless at a young age like 20, would actually be detracting from the wealth of their life? Everyone knows me as Penny and everyone makes effort to refer to me as feminine, of course there are many slip ups but it is always followed by an apology and a correction. I often say I dont mind because I know it wasnt meant in malice.
The times when I go to the shops or Library and am refered to as "mate","mr" or "him" it must be hard to tell that I am a woman with the stubble thing going on. I found solace with the idea that after the mones have taken affect and my stubble has been magic wonded away with the starwars laser satelite thingy that I will be more passable and might start to receive feminine referals instead.
Someone said to me, "Why do I do it to myself? Why dont I move somewhere where no one knows me?" - I supose you have to weigh up your life. This is where my daughter lives, I have loads of friends and I know the city very well, why on earth should I move? all for a few small minded idiots? no, I think I will stick around and make their lives a misery! haha
and one example, my neighbour must have recently figured out I am a trans woman because I have been receiving wolf whistles in a derogatory maner when I traverse to and from my abode. I have since reported this hate crime and I have been told that if it happens again that they will take action against this antisocial behaviour. I have to say, I was quite astounded by the proactive stance that was taken. Instead of feeling dirty and degraded by this sexual harisment I now feel conviction and proud to be who I am.
I supose, where it is a matter of quality of life with the affects of gender dsyphoria that one has to choose whether they can tolerate the odd incorrect referal of gender or uproot ones entire life and move to another city. My friends have been great but I can imagine how awful it must be if the majority of friends refered to me incorrectly. I wouldnt consider them as friends to keep.
Going stealth scares me, what if you got married and then got found out? I prefer to be able to sleep at night.
Love Penny x
ps, my internet got disconnected and they cant reconnect it until 4th Aug so I am having to access at our library so I wont be around much until then. make the most of it! lol
July 25, 2009 12:03 PM BST
Hi Marsha,
I've thought often of this over the years. My turn to begin transition is very near now and I've wondered how I would handle this issue. My first thoughts were to move elsewhere. Time to time I still consider it and perhaps I will. Very likely it won't even be necessary. Most people I know are gone from where I live, other than my wife's friends and acquaintances. I've spent a considerable amount of time away from home, especially during the last six years. As such, there aren't enough friends left here for me to concern myself with during the transition.
I can understand how others would feel about leaving and starting over somewhere else. Fifteen or so years ago I would have seriously considered the same. We would all like to be viewed and addressed as females. When you're surrounded by friends and acquaintances, that could be difficult and there will be the tendency for some to address you as "he", "him", "Mr.", etc., especially in mixed company. Relocating to a new city for a fresh start may be easier. Of course, as Lucy indicated, someone will discover the "old" you just by running a credit check for an apartment, home, new car, or even to open a new banking account. Some of that stealth will be lost. Perhaps not enough though to make a significant difference.
July 25, 2009 2:44 PM BST
There have been so many great posts here and in other forum threads recently that have really got me thinking. I'm starting to think the biggest reason why anyone would consider going stealth and moving is because while transitioning they were negatively accepted by family, friends and or coworkers.
I think the key here is not the people who don't accept you, but instead the key is the transition itself. What I mean about transition itself is the period where physical changes are actually happening and wardrobe changes occur. I think most have heard the saying "Too much change at once is bad for anyone." Don't forget your change is also causing change to others and they have to also adjust their lives. So everyday something new happens, facial hair removal, maybe facial surgery, just outward appearance, others have to adjust.
This has always been my argument about the Harry Benjamin SOC or now WPATH SOC. The SOC guidelines require we start living fulltime within 90 days of starting HRT. That means we have to "be in your face" with transition right in front of everyone in our lives. I believe this simple requirement has caused considerable harm to those transitioning over the years, causing loss of families, friends and employment. And so what if there are laws protecting your job, do you seriously want to work somewhere that nobody likes you?
I consider myself fortunate, very fortunate. I have my family, friends and the customers for my business intact. I did things differently than many. I literally transitioned right in front of everyone without them knowing for several years. People don't pick up on gradual changes nearly as fast as if you tell them things are changing. So when it came time for me to go fulltime I had people saying to me we always thought you were more feminine or even figuring me out before I could say anything. They have only had to deal with one change. Instead of being reminded constantly you were once a male and now changing to a female, they already see the female and have to work at remembering the male. Maybe that seems a stretch, but that is what worked for me.
Watch how girls here talk about how others have accepted them, often by all their friends that they hangout with. Something that often comes up is others have told them they always thought they were feminine so it all makes sense. I think that is what it is all about, making sense. If you lived or tried to live a macho guy life, I believe you are going to have a more difficult time with others accepting you. That just is too much for most people to comprehend. So by softening your behavior, others have one less adjustment and have time to accept you.
Transitioning is not all about starting HRT to grow boobs. HRT will not make you a woman. HRT is only one of the aids to bring your outer body inline with your inner side. Spend time letting others see your feminine side, without that nobody will see you as a woman no matter where you live. Transition is about others seeing your inner side and treating you accordingly. Transition is not all about changing your body. And if others see your inner side and treat you accordingly, do you really think going stealth has to be considered? I don't.
Hugs and best wishes to everyone,
Marsha
August 10, 2009 11:54 PM BST
Okay listen… I’m not trans and am not qualified to speak from any kind of personal experience. But, I have a number of trans friends, have seen a couple of trans ladies as GFs at one point (one of whom I still bear strong feelings for although I’ve been with a GG for around a year). …let’s just say that even as an outsider I do ‘get it’ or at least I like to believe that I do. That said, please take the followinbg for what it's worth.
Coming from a spiritual perspective rather than a trans-specific one…
There is something very profound and important—something spiritual--about heimat (MoHG “homelandâ€) that cannot be replaced in any other way. The smell of one’s hometown, the familiar faces, the activities that went on there and perhaps still do…
To move to another place where one is known by no one, the traditions are different, the laws are different… I’ve lived in 4 different states and fully understand the whole cultural thing about starting over.
I’m not going to suggest that one cannot find satisfaction in a new place with their lives filled with new people. HOWEVER there is something very important that is lost by rejecting everything that one once was, everyone once knew, and every place one had previously experienced. Is it really fair to you to rob yourself of this?
The trans journey is often a tough one. It’s hard enough as it is without disposing of all that was once important to you. A trans-woman (or man) goes through so many things just to be honest with herself that the majority of people don’t have to undergo. Does it make sense to not share that honesty with the important people in one’s life? How honest is that?
Yes, there are those who will have a HUGE problem trying to figure out how trasgenderism fits into your life. On the other hand, how many people—some of whom will be the last you expect—will offer not only understanding but even support?
As has already been pointed out, most are not “passable†and perhaps “passing†isn’t even the real question. Acceptance, support and people who really love you for being you are the important ones to find. I firmly believe that one can find these things without having to make the sacrifices required of living stealth.
There’s an old saying: “Why throw out the baby with the bathwater�
August 23, 2009 4:59 PM BST
This is one of the most thoughtful and insightful threads I have read on any board about any subject. Congratulations to all who participated. I am so glad I got to read it.
September 28, 2009 12:56 AM BST
I played football in high school [not much and not to good but I did it]. Was in the military. Became a powerlifter for about 20 years off and on. I tried to do the "male" thing for years and I died inside as a result. No need to elaborate as I am sure we have all gone through similar things. Anyone I told about me being transexual has left me. My family never speaks to me except my dad who has no clue what it is that I am and thinks TS are all homosexuals and of course his "son" can never be a homosexual.
I have no friends anymore except my wife. I have no family anymore either [5 brothers and 2 sisters].
For me stealth is just a given LOL. No one I use to know cares or gives a sheeeet.
Quite simply, I tried to transition in the early 80's and the doctors considered me a disease to be cured. I was beaten up and one day said the heck with it and stopped it all.
A few months ago I found out things had changed [via the internet]. Not much, but at least we are no longer a disease.
For me the idea of stealth is a given and I will definitely be doing such. My face will never been seen online or any place else in reference to me being TS.
As a matter of fact. I own 99% of all pictures ever taken of me and once I go full time I plan to destroy all references to me male past. I hate this body and have no desire to have anything to do with it any more then I absolutely have to.
As to whether one goes "stealth" or not I think is a highly personal and individual decision that only the person doing it can make.
I have memories of being outed [there was no internet or support groups etc as there are now to go to for information to how to "pass" etc]. And they are not pleasant at all.
So for me stealth is a given. As for anyone else, I feel it is a personal choice and I judge no one for the choice they make.
I hope this helps someone, not sure if it will or not though.
Stephenie
September 28, 2009 3:12 AM BST
Stephenie, as you say, going stealth is a personal thing. Personally I can't imagine going on with life without the people I know. You are more fortunate now that there are support sites such as TW available for the support you will need. Transition on your own is lonely and I know that firsthand. The people at TW saved my life and bought me time for my family to better understand and eventually accept what was going on with me. Transition is something that takes years and that will need to be done in front of people who will know your past. To go stealth assumes you will go somewhere nobody knows you after you transition. I think it is way too early for you to make a decision to go stealth. Many of us are near 100% passable at first glance, however given more opportunity most of us can and will be read. Then what? Move again?
Best wishes,
Marsha
September 29, 2009 12:20 PM BST
Marsha hi
I was mostly commenting on my family and what happened about 35 years ago and how they threw me away. My friends left me about 25 years ago when they found out I was serious about becoming a woman. Weird in that about the same time I stopped trying because of the doctors etc etc.
Now I am trying again and my wife is supportive. My family hasn't spoken to me in decades and the few friends I do have , well I have no idea what they will do. As for support now a days I think the internet is a fantastic place as is places like this as well. If I had had places like this decades ago I think I could have persevered. Who knows.
As for stealth. I have no intention of wearing a sandwich board saying "I am TS like it or lump it". I also see no reason whatsoever that anyone else needs to know either.
I have no intention of saying to someone I am TS. To me all it means is that I am a woman that had a horrible birth defect that has been corrected [or will be one day].
No one with a corrected birth defect goes around telling everyone they are a birth defect. They just get on with life. So for me stealth is mostly just getting on with life.
Not sure if it does but I hope that clears things up Marsha
Stephenie
July 17, 2009 2:53 PM BST
Marsha, it's always a tricky one isn't it? I think the reality for me, if it were to happen, was that going stealth just wouldn't be a realistic option as my life is at the moment. I think it is difficult for those who may have known us for 10 - 20 years to see us as female, but I believe that's balanced by those that do. The issue of using the wrong pronoun is easily corrected and isn't something to get upset about, not in the long run, as it is never meant as an insult but is just a mistake. One that happens to GG's as well, (I've seen it more than once).
The other part of me is against stealth simply because I am proud of who i am, so why would I want to hide my past? It's a hell of a tough road to take as we know so why pretend it didnt' happen. Just my opinion of course and as I'm rather bolsy and not the type to shy away, I appreciate that it would not be the right choice for others.
I guess there's is that fact that sometimes the choice is made for you as well. If your current situation is not good, then a fresh start by going stealth may very well be the right choice. I don't think I would really know for sure until I was in that position.
Nikki
July 17, 2009 2:59 PM BST
for me going stealth meant moving to a new town where I can shops and socialise without the crap of being seen as that p/q/f/bif etc...makes life so much better.
i found it really annoying that after two ful years of transition I was still seen as him etc.
July 17, 2009 7:45 PM BST
The idea of leaving the place that I love and disowning all my friends, and possibly avoiding my family in public is slightly abhorrent to me.
I do not believe that our friends will never see us as female, but I suspect that depends on your friends. Of course, they will always remember us as male, is that such a bad thing? I think this is the real problem that some girls have with friends who know their past; they simply don’t want to be remembered as male.
My friends, without exception, never, ever use male pronouns, never ever treat me any differently to how they would any other female. Maybe I’m just lucky, or maybe you need to have a quiet chat with your friends.
Being stealth means that no-one has any idea you are trans, so unless you are entirely certain you pas completely, all the time, in any situation, then there is nothing to think about. You will be no better off in a town where no-one knows you than one where everyone knows you. Perhaps worse off, friends and allies are no bad thing, for anyone.
I’d live stealth if I could, but I would never lose all my friends and give up everything I have here just to achieve it. The question is academic because I don’t pass all the time.
Do you?
xx
July 17, 2009 8:17 PM BST
I think it's a very tiny percentage of girls who pass completly 100% and 100% of the time. It's very hard to get absolutely everything right, including the voice and the reality is, most of don't get there. It doesn't matter though, it's not about passing, it's about living your life as you see fit and with the minimum about of agravation, and that holds true whether you are TG or not.
Nikki
July 17, 2009 11:55 PM BST
I'm unlikely to ever pass without notice. That does make me a bit sad and regretful of the era I grew up in, before it was possible to understand what I was and do something about it while it was still possible for me to pass. Of course I would like that. I've seen my genes feminized and I would have made a cute girl if action had been available in time. I'm still hunting for the Pink Button to push, like so many of us. Although I would far prefer to be a girl than a guy, It seems very likely (but not certain) that I am not quite TS, but two-spirit, and my only issue is whether to live openly so or hide it from most.. So for me, living as who I am would deny stealth as a lifestyle option. It will make it obvious that I am "specially gendered".
There are two things I have gained. Self-acceptance and friendship. It has been some time since I reached the point where I would give up TW and my friends and acquaintances here for those who know me only as "him". I would fear losing you all far more than losing my pre-TW friends, who I spend far, far less time with. It will be up to them to decide if they continue to value my friendship. I'm already where I would not deny being TG if asked. I once, long ago, decided I would rather die than be bullied any more. Now I would rather die than deny myself the rest of the life that I mostly missed out on. So I have to move Out. I started this new path during L.A. Pride. It was NOT a fun day. It was just a normal day, alone in a crowd. No, truthfully, it was a kind of crappy day. I ended up with a sore toe and a sunburn. What I wore made little difference after the first 15 minutes in public. In fact, I would have gotten more attention en homme than I did en femme. I was just Wendy, another person in the crowd., in the heat, in the transportation-challenged streets of Hollywood-West Hollywood. . This was kind of amazing. So stealth is out for some very practical and some very unalterable reasons. I'm an In-betweenie, perhaps a Tom-Boy.
However, there is one overwhelming reason that would prevent me from living my life Stealthy. I did that for many, many years. I never want to live with that fear of discovery again. The time since I decided if I got Outed by accident I'd just deal with it has been so much more peaceful for me. I could not imagine, transitioning, having a family and home and living in constant fear of being exposed. Never again! For those of you who wish it, I understand. I give hope that you are granted the life you pursue and never set off a buried landmine that will expose your history. I won't walk that minefield ever again. My addition of the third quote below is a reflection of that decision.
Game theory demonstrates that the same payoff can hold different values for different people. We must each write in the number that reflects the value of our choice-payoff combination to ourselves.
July 18, 2009 2:18 AM BST
“it's not about passing…”
I’m assuming Nikki isn’t specifically referring to stealth here, because if stealth isn’t about passing then I am obviously misunderstanding the definition of stealth.
And here we are back to definitions again. It’s fine if you see stealth as being “this”, or “not quite that”, I wouldn’t argue with you. But my opinion…
I kind of think the definition of “stealth” is like that of “fulltime”, in as much as - it’s an all or nothing type of thing. You are either fulltime or not, if you are ever in drab, ever go into male mode at all, you aren’t fulltime; there is no such thing as “mostly fulltime”. Similarly with “stealth”: “I’m stealth apart from the people who know about me…” isn’t quite stealth to me, therefore it’s not at all. It doesn’t matter who knows or who cares, or even who is suspicious. As far as everyone is concerned – you were born female and no-one would have any reason to question that. These types are indeed a tiny percentage, and good for them.
“Do you think that blob on the radar is a stealth plane?"
“Could be, should we shoot it down just in case?”
A stealth plane wouldn’t even be on the radar.
Confide in just one person and you lose your stealth status.
Even total passability is no guarantee to maintaining stealth; your credit report, easily accessible to many people, will show all past names you have been known by, and of course the gender that goes with them. Inland Revenue will always know, NHS will always know, most of your future employers will find out. Some records are seemingly indestructible.
If stealth really mattered to me, I’d live with a dark cloud over me all the time.
I’d rather be Little Miss Sunshine.
xx
July 18, 2009 8:39 AM BST
you pass so well the women are jealous of you (apart from the lesbians who desire you) and the men give you that stare cos they find you attractive and wish to let you know they see you as prey in the mating game.
Your Mums constant use of your former name shows she hopes that one day you will snap out of it...
I consider my self to have passed if I can walk past a group of people and get nothing but a cursory glance.
July 18, 2009 8:52 AM BST
I don't think being outed is a fearful thing but more of an annoyance that the outer is so small minded. And with my work and lifestyle I don't slavishly follow the same route at the same time as thousands of others so I work on the theory that if I am outed it will either be an insignificant thing to ignore or if it is serious I can pull out my phone and call the police as here in the UK we have really good Hate Crime laws.
July 18, 2009 12:16 PM BST
There was a girl here that posted a thread on this same topic a couple of years ago.
All she wanted to be was a woman. She was post op, young , & good looking. But she felt she would never realy be seen as a woman as long as people thought of her as that TS girl. So for her to fully complete her transformation she wanted to be where people didn't see the TS but the woman. She just wanted a clean start.
I moved for a very simular reason. I was a drug addict & everyone knew it. After I got clean I couldn't get rid of being thought of as an addict. So I moved to be able to start over.
The same with her.
July 18, 2009 3:42 PM BST
I think it's more about who are you today. A woman or a post-op TS.
July 20, 2009 9:49 AM BST
In reply to Julie, have you considered that, many of them are embarressed,, to get close to you, befreind you they probably think, that others will think they are weird? Sorta guilt by association, Real men will not accept for egotistical reasons that any man would want to change sides, Gay men probably get more acceptance in the work place. Its a penis thing, not many men could concieve of another man per se as willing to sacrifice what is so important to them. Women on the other hand tend to me more conciitory. I have a couple of women freinds, their husbands are outraged, lol. On that point, as far as women are concerned it might be empathy of style and taste lol, a shopping thing. Can be likened to a woman wearing stockings and sexy underwear whilst bonking and he wears scruffy boxers or Y fronts and socks and he thinks thats cool, lol. Perhaps men do have latent TV tendancies, lol, perhaps some of them dress in secret, the best form of defence is attack. Perhaps its the women that wear the trousers in the relationship, and they feel there is enough pressure of being under the thumb without king men turning into women, lol. Your a traitor to the misquided theory that men are superior and rule all?
xxXCristineXxx
July 20, 2009 12:47 PM BST
To date, I don't think any woman I have met has had an issue with TG, curiousity yes, that's understandable, but there is no malice involved. Men on the other hand just can't or won't understand it. I think it's as Chrisine says, they just can't get their heads round someone wanting to get rid of their penis. they have no idea of the concept at all so typically of them, what they don't understand, they attack.
Karen - good analogy. I can see why that would have been the right move for you.
Since I tend to move around with work anyway, being in one place isn't a particular issue so I would carry on as normal. I suppose to some degree that is stealthy since I'm not in the same town I was 10 years ago for example but I still go back there to see old friends so whatever works for you really.
Julie - I think the pronouns etc are deliberate, at least it sounds that way to me. You were once male therefore you are still thought of as that. It's totally wrong and shouldn't be allowed. I'm pretty sure in the UK you could be prosecuted for that, (emotional harrassment or something similar), I have seen very good Tgirls being refered to as 'you know it's a bloke though?' I mean, c'mon, does she look like a guy????
Men..........is it any wonder we don't want to be one anymore?
Nikki
August 16, 2009 11:17 PM BST
Marsha, I think you are right about gradual changes going unnoticed or unremarked. Recently, one of my closest friends spent the day with me and suddenly exclaimed, "You are wearing earrrings!" I stopped, looked at him with a puzzled expression, and said "I've had earrings for years. You just noticed?" He had just noticed.
*******************
If you move to maintain stealth you lose one important asset. Your community history. People will take 10-20 years to learn what you are like as a person. The years you lived before become non-existent. Do you really want to lose the assurance to everyone that you are an OK person. Even if you are not Outed in your Stealth life elsewhere, trust will have to be rebuilt over time. I spent 9 years in a new home as a child and was never accepted as a local. My grandparents had not lived there. Think about what you will give up. For me, this is easy. I grew up doing it over and over. It may be very difficult if you have not done it before.