November 2, 2010 3:41 PM GMT
http://www.pfc.org.uk/node/340
Published in the UK law forum. some time ago.
This is a case that set a judicial ruling and was refered to in the case of Cambridge Health authority. Regarding this particular case the North West Lankashire Health Authority subsequently appealed the judgement and lost.......................................more
The original cost as to each appellants surgery was muted at £8000. Total cost for this case and the subsequent appeal by the HA.was in the region of £1.2M the health authority paying to order 66% of costs and 33% being paid by legal aid, so basically 100% by the tax payer, this did not include compensation or any punative damages. David/Sonia was one of the leading solicitors for one of the claimants in the original case briefing QC's, and yes that case whilst did not exactly initially force a change of view on the British government or the health service, but it was a major contributing factor that heralded the birth of the UK Gender Recognition Act.. I never knew or even met her, but I do know several people that had. She will be missed, Her selfless dedication to the oppressed and people deserving basic human rights was only to be admired. Her death might be the result of one mad moment,, initiated by despondancy and despair.
Leave the crap out of it. Once again its a case of ''people who live in glass houses should'nt throw stones'' I hope we are all remembered for the one good thing we did, rather than a few things we did'nt, seems lately people are more interested in someones private life than the good and lasting affect their lives have had on our own rights and freedoms.
November 2, 2010 3:47 PM GMT
Thank you, Cristine. I thought I remembered you posting something on one of her cases listed in the obituary.
Best,
Melody
November 2, 2010 3:58 PM GMT
I am not trying to justify the act of murder in any way Melody, nor am I trying to argue any point here. I'm just adding my take on the story which might be similar to how the Evening Standard story went. I had noted this individual seemed to be well respected and your latest link also had a very positive view of Sonia. Right now all we know is speculation, and as your latest post eluded to the answers to what happened may never be known, and it may have even been a tragic accident, not murder.
We often want to say people who don't accept us are ignorant. It is also ignorant to believe that all transgendered do no wrong. Both are human nature and in each person's mind they have good intentions. So my statement may have been harsh, yet it is as feasible as any others given.
Hugs,
Marsha
November 2, 2010 4:19 PM GMT
I can see your point Marsha,
What I don't get is this insatiable quest to dig the dirt, by a free newspaper, we all know dirt sells papers. but its left there for people to read between the lines and probably come to the wrong conclusion, to put the emphasis on the more sordid aspects of Trans issues, rather than highlight the good works achieved. articles like this does us no favours. thats why I find it abhorant.
November 2, 2010 4:30 PM GMT
I totally agree Cris. I don't want to come across as being insincere. I wish there was a way to balance what is said on the topic. At least for those interested, the internet gives those of us who care, alternative sites to see stories from different angles.
Hugs,
Marsha
November 2, 2010 5:33 PM GMT
Perhaps this rings so loudly in the ears of us in the UK because our gutter press has a long and dubious history of hounding people into the ground if they sniff a lurid story. It has only been in recent years that our redtop Sunday "newpapers" have stopped reporting and outing a TS merely for being TS, with headlines like "Busty Blonde Brenda The Coal Miner In Sexswop Sensation". Two now quite famous transexual women were outed in this way and had their careers destroyed.
November 3, 2010 3:51 PM GMT
I have always said that the news rags have never reported news. They just sensationalise stories under the guise of news to encourage ignorant people to buy their papers. Ignorant papers attract ignorant readers. Proper news is a little too boring.
With the diversity laws and such in place, put there by government mechanisms, it shows that news papers are independant and have the freedom to express their opinions. Can you imagine what laws might be enforced if the ignorant news papers ran government? All m2f Trannies would be forced to wear 4" high heals, blonde wigs, mini skirts, horendous makeup and work in the sex trade not forgetting being chained to the kitchen sink.
Love
Penny
x