"Estro-Maxx" SNL's parody of trans women

    • 308 posts
    February 3, 2011 5:44 AM GMT
    Wow Jen, you hit that one right on. Comedy is not what it used to be.
    But here is a link from the comments concerning this skit, that states the point so very well.
    >>>>>>>>>>>>>
    SNL’s “Estro-Maxx” Skit On Gender Transition Is No Joke
         By Anthony Moll
    February 2nd, 2011 at 9:49 am

    The following is from Meghan Stabler, a member of HRC’s Board of Directors:

    http://www.hrcbackstory.o[...]o-joke/
    • Moderator
    • 252 posts
    January 31, 2011 2:12 PM GMT
    Two days ago, Saturday Night Live premiered a new episode. For me, SNL has always been a welcome diversion after a long week. But this time was different. If you don't know the show, it is a comedy sketch show. They do lots of current political stuff, but this week it was our turn.

    They unveiled a new "fake" commercial. It was called "Estro-Maxx. The once a day pill." Here's the link to the skit: http://www.nbc.com/saturd[...]279560/

    I was laughing a little bit until they brought out a "trans woman" with a full beard. I was watching with my friends and I noticed they were laughing pretty heartily. As I mentioned on FB, I suddenly felt very tired and decided not to say anything about how hurtful it was to me.

    I realize SNL has a long history of skewering different segments of the population. Unfortunately, most people see us as either a joke or fodder for porn. Is it truly fair when there isn't a "baseline" for "ordinary" trans women?

    There is already a FB group set up to have NBC apologize for the sketch. Here's the FB group: http://www.facebook.com/h[...]91&ap=1

    I guess I don't have anything else to say. I feel that everyone is laughing about a joke they think is fairly real, without knowing that the joke has absolutely no grounding in reality. When the general public knows next to nothing about who you are, this kind of thing is, in my humble opinion, extremely damaging.

  • February 3, 2011 12:07 PM GMT
    I laughed at this because it made me think of the "miracle potions" from transformation et al, and all the wild claims they make about being able to turn someone resembling Bernard Manning into Jane Mansfield
  • January 31, 2011 3:46 PM GMT
    Children's slapstick about sums it up, Lucy, but it leaves Children with the wrong perception about transgendered people Something like some of the comedy programmes we see on British Television,. Little Britain. Cigarettes have warning labels about health issues, perhaps programmes like this should have warning labels ''this in no way depicts the serious issues of being transgendered''
    • 1652 posts
    January 31, 2011 3:18 PM GMT
    If the link Zoe posted doesn't work this one might:
    http://www.youtube.com/wa[...]hqZ4hu4
    But I don't get it, transgender or not, why's it supposed to be funny?
    Bearded men in dresses is one down from chidren's slapstick. Not what I'd call comedy.
    xx
    • 6 posts
    January 31, 2011 2:36 PM GMT
    I tried viewing this, but as I am in the UK it was not possible however, there are always going to be people who are going to take the piss and parody us, sometimes lightheartedly, and sometimes cruelly. It comes down to whether we choose to be offended, or hurt by it. If you are, they win. If you are not, they lose and the event is soon forgotten. Full acceptance by society will not happen in my lifetime so I choose to be satisfied with the acceptance that I have from those who know me, and stuff the rest.
    • 1017 posts
    January 31, 2011 5:42 PM GMT
    Hi Zoey,

    Saturday Night Live (nee NBC Saturday Night) has been around for more than 35 years and ran out of comedic steam by the late 1970's. A few funny comedians have passed through since then, but mostly is bland, stupid and offensive without being clever. Think most folks watch if for the guest host of the week rather than for the skits.

    Don't think it has much effect of people's views of anything these days. I wouldn't worry much about it making fun of TGs.

    Best,
    Mellie