July 25, 2005 9:05 PM BST
Wow, Clair, what an exceptionally interesting and very thought provoking article, thank you so much for sharing it with. I read through the whole thing without jotting down any notes or anything and I certainly didn't take the time to look up any of the footnotes or references. But I certainly had quite the mixed bag of feelings while I was reading it. Of course I intend to read it again and to share it with friends who are not part of Tranny Web.
My thoughts are that while I can find certain particulars to take exception to, all in all I agree with the gist of the article. Speaking personally, which is all I suppose I really can do, if I could make this an ideal world I would be able to dress however I pleased. If I felt like donning full regalia I could and if I felt like wearing boy jeans and a cute flowery top I could do that too.
As to being forced to "overdress" (my phrase, not his) when I go out en femme in order to fool others into thinking I'm a woman, I don't delude myself that that's what's happening. I'm not that passable, but to be honest, I really do enjoy the feeling of being dressed as a woman and I'm as likely to wear jeans and a t-shirt as a skirt or dress.
To each his own. as far as how you want to dress and the gender manifestation you want to present to the world. I do feel that there is an "all or nothing" sort of undercurrent in the transgendered world, just as he says, and that if you can't "pass" you better just get yourself back in the closet and forget all about it. It would be much better, my opnion again, if we could all just dress and act in the way that feels right for us instead of conforming ourselves to old and rigid stereotypes of what we should be and how we should act.
Okay, I'm done (for now, anyway). Otherwise I'll just go on and on. I hope there are lots more comments, which I'm sure there will be and I also most sincerely hope that they will shed light rather than heat.
Thanks, Clair.
Hugs...Joni