July 26, 2007 1:05 AM BST
Thank you so much to everybody for your responses. I'm sorry that it's taken me a little longer than I would have liked to reply but I was thinking about what everybody has said... and (a bit shamefully might I add) I haven't quite yet worked out how to reply to topics! I hope that how I've done it now might have worked, but I have the feeling that I might have ended up quoting Rachel instead
Well, firstly, a few people have asked if my boyfriend is a member of TW. Not as far as I am aware. I found this place by googling. And well, I know that he's a member of other TV websites and so in a way it's nice for me to have somewhere to come and talk about things away from the conversations that I have with him. I would prefer if he didn't know that I post on here as in a way I feel like if he did so it might make him feel a bit self-conscious, and I would rather talk about the situation without him having it rammed down his throat.
Well last night we had a very positive conversation. I brought up the fact that I hadn't seen his, well I don't really know how to describe it - 'feminine identity' perhaps - for a while and asked if he was okay, and if she was okay. I think that he was a bit bemused by this, but then I went on to explain that I had noticed how, since my little crying session last month, I haven't heard anything more about his 'feminine identity' (let's call her Ruth) and asked why. I told him that I know that he loves me and cares about me and doesn't want to hurt me, but that I was concerned that he may be suppressing a part of himself due to my reaction last month. We talked for a very long time about it. He explained to me that he isn't at all sure that he really is TV because, until a few weeks ago, it was all very risque for him to dress up, however since he told me and I basically let him get on with it it's lost it's appeal in a way. From what he said it seems like he doesn't want to have it as a 'lifestyle choice' (his own words) but likes to dress up every now and again for a thrill. I've reassured him that that's fine with me, but that if 'Ruth' does want to come out and visit again then to please tell me as I'd like to meet her properly. After the conversation my mind feels more at ease, because we've had a real heart to heart more than anything, and he seemed really happy about the conversation too. Hopefully the fact that I've made it clear that I love him no matter what and I would actually like to get to know his feminine identity has made him feel at ease and he'll find it easier to bring these things up in future if he ever wants to.
Following on from that conversation we had a wonderful conversation about our future. I know that I'm only young - he's slightly older than me - but I really do love this wonderful man so very much, and all I want is for him to be happy and content. And for me to be a part of that.
July 26, 2007 12:17 PM BST
Alecia,
I can only speak for myself but I think it applies to many here at TW. I believe in the early stages of "dressing" we ourselves are trying to figure out why we do it and because society has mislabeld this a sexual thing and we were brought up with these same beliefs, we tend to lean towards the "risque" attire early on. As we come to understand our situation more and become comfortable with our feminine side, our efforts tend to go towards just being one of the girls, what we call "passing." It is a mixed bag though, on one hand we are comfortable and relaxed, and on the other we fear being found out. Your boyfriend may right now see this as an escape, a little personal time that he is not ready to share. I don't think you need to overwhelm him with acceptance at this point, but simple occassional reassurances that you will always be there for him will make a huge difference. Maybe simple comments like "how are your friends online doing?" or "I'm going to the store I need some makeup, do you need anything?" It's funny how we ask society to accept us, yet we have a side of us that wants to keep hiding. Take it easy, things won't change overnight. Good luck, it sounds like your a wonderful person.
July 26, 2007 7:44 PM BST
We each have our own form of gender identity expression, and it changes and evolves over time, especially when we are able to overcome the isolation in which so many transgender people spend so much of their lives. As you both become more comfortable sharing this aspect of your boyfriend's identity, you will see him develop his feminine identity further, and define a form of expression that works for both of you. Just be patient. Something tells me that you are just the sort of person who is able to do so.
July 27, 2007 11:30 PM BST
Robyn is right in saying that the individual's expression of gender identity is unique.
My own experience has made me realise that I'm in a relationship with a unique & beautiful individual, who, at will takes on masculine & feminine traits (like a chameleon). It's so hard to get used to at first, but, with perseverence, you suddenly realise that you have the perfect combination- a girlfriend & boyfriend in one!
My weirdest moment was when, during one of our "girly" nights, I totally forgot who I was talking to & had a real heart to heart about**** & Abi listened & gave me advice & even criticised him! Believe me, that really screwed my mind!
Now, in our first home together, it's weird 'cause there's so much to get done & Abi doesn't come out so often- mainly 'cause there's so much to do. However, there's a new identity, one that we've struggled to give a name to- half man, half woman. I come home to find him doing housework, wearing one of my skirts, pretty satin sequin slippers, a frumpy man's "comfy" jumper & no makeup.
When I've asked him why, he's responded that it's just easy, comfy clothes- pretty much the same sort of stuff I'll slob around wearing on a weekend while doing the same stuff!
So, as I & others have said, differing degrees.
Take care,
Gillian
July 24, 2007 9:11 PM BST
Hi Alicea,
Your boyfriend is as scared and confused as you are. He may still be coming to terms with his transgenderism himself, we don't usually accept it immediately and are worried what others will think and say, and will we lose loved ones over this?
You have been very understanding about this so far, and it has been a complete shock to you I'm sure. I know it was for each of my wives when I told them. The fact that you haven't gone running screaming for the door or called him all sorts of unpleasant names speaks volumes.
I think you have it in you to find a balance that you can both be happy with, many including myself have done so, but it takes both of you to make it work, which means openess and honesty and no more running around behind your back.
I hope you manage to find a solution that works for you. There is a lot of advise and forums on the subject here so it will help you to read through them and at least know your situation isn't unique.t You're not alone.
Good luck Alicea,
Nikki
July 24, 2007 10:55 PM BST
Hi Alicea,
I’m glad Gillian has replied (and so wonderfully) because it might seem like replies from just trannies are biased and one-sided.
Without doubt your boyfriend is scared about this. Perhaps the scariest thing for any TG person in the closet is being accidentally discovered. If he displayed any anger towards you finding out, I can assure you that he’s not really angry with you, he’s scared. The anger is just a defence mechanism when there is no other obvious way to react. Like you, I’m sure all S/O’s wish their partner could be open and honest about everything in that sort of situation, but the fear is crippling, and may make some of us act strangely, and out of character.
As has been said, trying to suppress this side of his nature will not work for either of you, it's virtually impossible for him to do that – it’s just a part of him, but because he loves you he will try and hide it from you so as not to upset you. Which ain't gonna work, because the hiding things is just as upsetting.
Ideally you need to try to accept this side of him, and that it doesn’t make him any less of a person, or mean that he loves you any less. Then you must encourage him to be open and honest about it, assure him that there is no need to be secretive about his dressing. You don’t have to pretend that it’s easy for you, but it’s the only way you are likely to work things through and stay together. If there are lines you are not ready to cross then be clear; certain “rules” will be a lot easier for him to abide by rather than trying to persuade him not to dress at all. If you don’t like him wearing your clothes for example, then that could be a rule. If he has your blessing to be able to express his true self then I’m sure he will respect those sort of stipulations.
Don’t be hurt that he’s kept things from you, it’s a fairly terrifying secret to have, but now that you know the truth there should be no need for any more secrets, so you have to encourage him not to try and hide things.
I admire you for coming here Alicea and doing your best to deal with this sensibly and rationally, the world needs more teenagers like you!
Best of luck to you both, you will find lots of support and friendly advice on this site.
xx
July 25, 2007 2:41 AM BST
Wow, Keli, first time I've ever had a post pre-reviewed, lol.
Alecia, there are three things that seem to be stereotypical of the situation you find yourself in.
1. Your heterosexual crossdressing boyfriend (I'm guessing, but most TGs are heterosexual males) is not going to stop being TG, ever, and is unlikely to be able to stop dressing en femme for any length of time. To even try is usually very bad for the TG and can crate a lot of negative psychological problems.
2. His biggest issue is likely to be embarrassment at the threat to his masculinity of his crossdressing being known to another person he actually has contact with.
3. Your biggest issue is likely to be with having been "lied" to. Know that it happens because of both intense fear and love for you.
If you two can learn to deal with these issues, you can have a wonderful relationship. Having a boyfriend who can also be a girl friend is a very emotionally satisfying relationship for many SOs. Women have asked my SO if she rents me out when seeing us shopping together because we have FUN. Having my SO bring me jewelry and clothing gives me a wonderful sense of acceptance and has given me a much wider wardrobe. We have even bought matching articles of clothing and share things with each other. I send her subscriptions to clothing catalogs and she brings me fashion magazines. We have plans to see a chick flick together next month.
Telling her was the scariest thing I ever did in my life. I don't know how I would have dealt with her finding out years ago. Knowing how I used to be, I probably would have gotten angry.
I can't recommend MEN ARE FROM MARS, WOMEN ARE FROM VENUS (and Lucy is from a planet in between) is a great book. I can't recommend it enough if you want to understand how to support your SO emotionally. It will let you learn how while not being hurt by what is happening.
This can be a wonderful thing for both of you. It's going to take a lot of knowledge, work, support and trust from both of you. Good luck.
July 26, 2007 2:43 AM BST
I usualy stay out of these threads because I'm not in a relationship.
The one girl that did know thought it was only about sex & she was all for that.
I like the way you say you had a talk with him & let him know you except him as is.
I would have liked to have met a person like yourself at some point in my life.
Keeping this site to yourself sounds like a good idea. A place where you can talk with out fear of what you wish to say.
Good luck!!!
July 26, 2007 8:07 AM BST
I'm so glad to hear this Alicea, and being TG isn't always about a change of lifestyle, although some do go 'all the way', others are content with a little cross dressing now and then. We are all different in how we are affected by being transgendered.
You sound very understanding and it seems that more and more people are seeing nothing wrong with this kind of life that we lead, which can only be a positive thing for everbody it concerns, wives, girlfriends and families included. Once the stigma and discrimination that forces us to remain in the closet is removed, it can only strengthen relationships since there will be no more need to keep secrets from our partners for fear of losing them.
It seems to me that you two have a great thing going, so don't be suprised if this actually makes your relationship much stronger. Best wishes to you both.
Nikki