January 21, 2009 10:26 AM GMT
Actually, I'm not terribly upset with this person's point of view. It is wrong, solely because it is based on the idea that the body, not the brain, is the center of gender identity. The argument is largely rational; just based on a false premise. If he was to accept the "brain sometimes does not switch to male in some XY eggs" view, he might just change his argument's conclusion. That he is "wrong" is based in his ignorance of developmental biology, not lack of logic. Faith, in religion or scientific theory, can be mislead from the facts. There is a certain responsibility to question if the "truth" you base your stand on is really T or, in fact, F which (as any student of symbolic logic will tell you) leads to a false conclusion if all other premises are T.
As for The Pope, any man who wears frocks and silk slippers 24/7, has no place telling me I am wrong to wear a dress. Does he look in the mirror?